GrailMine
How it worksPeer TradeTrust systemShippingFees
Sign inJoin the exchange

GrailMine Protection

Draft · The effective date is set at launch.

This page, from Rift Exchange, LLC ("GrailMine," "we," "us"), explains what happens when an order goes wrong, who is protected, and how. It summarizes how GrailMine's claims process works for buyers and sellers. The Terms of Service are the binding document, and if this page and the Terms differ, the Terms control.

1. How Protection Works on GrailMine

Protection on GrailMine is a process, not an insurance policy.

  • The seller's share goes into the seller's own Stripe account. You pay GrailMine, and the seller's share of the payment goes straight into the seller's own account with our payment provider; only GrailMine's fees stay with GrailMine. GrailMine does not hold the seller's money for them.
  • The payout is released on delivery. The seller's share can be paid out to their bank once the carrier confirms delivery, at every order size, or 14 days after the carrier's acceptance scan if the carrier never records delivery. Released earnings are paid out every Friday, or when the seller cashes out. A payout is paused only while a claim on the order is open (up to 10 business days; a counterfeit claim pauses it until 10 business days after GrailMine receives the card, and never more than 30 days after the claim opened), while GrailMine investigates suspected fraud (up to 30 days), or while a chargeback is open (until the card network decides, or 90 days after it opens).
  • Refunds are paid by GrailMine and recovered from the seller. When a claim is decided for the buyer, the refund is issued from GrailMine's own funds. GrailMine does not take the seller's share back to pay it. Instead, the seller owes GrailMine a recorded debt, which GrailMine recovers as described in section 3.2. GrailMine keeps no fee on a refunded order.

2. For Buyers

2.1 What You Can Claim

ClaimWhen you can bring it
Item not receivedWithin 30 days after the order's expected delivery date.
Not as described (condition, completeness, or any other way it differs from the listing)Within 30 days after the order's expected delivery date, or within 30 days after the order is delivered, if that is later.
Counterfeit or not genuineWithin 30 days after delivery. This longer window covers authenticity only.

A card that arrives damaged is the seller's responsibility: the seller bears transit risk, and GrailMine refunds you without waiting for a carrier claim. For a parcel shipped without following the packaging requirements in the Seller Shipping Standards, that is so whatever the carrier did.

How a refund works, including cancellations before shipping, is explained in the Return and Refund Policy.

All sales on GrailMine are final. There are no returns for buyer's remorse or a change of mind. Before a full refund on a not-as-described claim, the buyer sends the card back to the seller on a prepaid tracked label that GrailMine provides, to the seller's return address. The buyer has 14 days from when the label is issued to ship it, or the claim closes with no refund. GrailMine refunds the buyer 3 business days after the carrier delivers the card to the seller, or sooner if the seller confirms receipt. During those 3 days the seller can report a wrong or damaged card, with photos, and an administrator decides the claim before any refund is made. The cost of the label is added to what the seller owes only if a refund is issued. If the card is lost on the return label, the buyer is refunded anyway, the seller bears the loss as part of what they owe, and GrailMine files the carrier claim, applies any payment to what the seller owes and pays the seller any remainder. A seller who settles a claim by refunding can choose not to ask for the card back, and that refund is made at once. The seller can make one partial-refund offer on a not-as-described claim: if the buyer accepts, the claim settles and the buyer keeps the card; if the buyer declines, the claim continues and either side can escalate it. An administrator can only decide a full refund, with the card sent back, or deny the claim. The seller's payout is paused until 10 business days after the card is delivered to the seller, and never more than 30 days after the claim was opened. A counterfeit card is handled under section 2.3.

2.2 How a Claim Is Decided

  1. Open a dispute from the order. The seller's payout stays on hold while it is open, and the seller is notified.
  2. The seller can respond, ask for more information, or refund you directly. A refund from the seller ends the dispute in your favor.
  3. If it is not settled, either you or the seller can escalate it to a GrailMine administrator. If the seller does not respond to a not-as-described claim within 3 business days, the claim goes to a GrailMine administrator, who decides it as usual; it is not decided for the buyer automatically. A dispute with no activity for seven days is withdrawn automatically, and you can open it again while the claim window is open. A claim waiting on a send-back (the buyer's 14 days to ship the card) or in the seller's 3-business-day review is not withdrawn automatically.
  4. You can withdraw your dispute at any time before an administrator acts, and whoever escalated can retract the escalation. A reason is required either way. A withdrawn dispute carries on as if it had not been opened, and you can open it again.
  5. An administrator reviews the evidence and decides. Evidence includes the listing photographs, any live inspection recording, tracking and delivery records, packaging compliance, and an unboxing video or sealed-package photographs if either side has them. Those last two are encouraged but not required.
  6. If you win, you are refunded in full, including the shipping and handling charge, from GrailMine's funds, and GrailMine recovers the cost from the seller as a debt. If the seller wins, the payout is released to the seller.

Closed disputes stay in your dispute history.

2.3 Counterfeit Claims

Before GrailMine refunds a counterfeit claim, you must send the card to GrailMine on a prepaid tracked label that GrailMine provides, whatever the card is worth. You have 14 days from when the label is issued; if the card is not sent, the claim is closed without a refund. GrailMine refunds you once it receives the card and confirms it is the card shown in the listing or the live inspection session recording. A confirmed counterfeit is never returned to you or to the seller. If the card you send is not the card in the listing or recording, the claim is denied. If GrailMine finds the card is genuine, it returns the card to you at its own expense and decides the claim like any other. The seller's payout is paused until 10 business days after GrailMine receives the card, and never more than 30 days after the claim was opened. If the card is lost on GrailMine's prepaid label, the buyer is refunded, GrailMine bears the loss, and the seller owes nothing and is paid as usual.

Within 14 days of GrailMine's finding that a card is counterfeit, the seller (or, in a Peer Trade, the Sender) can ask GrailMine to send the card to PSA, Beckett, CGC, SGC or TAG for a grading review. While that window is open, and while a review is pending, the card is not destroyed or turned over unless the law requires it. GrailMine ships the card to the grader, and the grader returns it to GrailMine, never to the user. The card counts as authenticated only if the grader authenticates it as genuine, returns it sealed in its holder, and the certificate number matches the grader's online record. Any other result means GrailMine keeps the card. The user pays the grader's fee and the shipping to and from the grader, as a debt, and bears the risk of loss in transit beyond the insurance; GrailMine applies any carrier payment to what the user owes and pays the user the remainder. In a Peer Trade dispute after delivery, where the card is GrailMine's, GrailMine bears the risk in transit and keeps any carrier payment. If the card is authenticated, GrailMine reimburses the grading and shipping costs, returns the card in its sealed holder at its own expense, reverses any account action and charges no fees; the refund to the buyer stands, and the seller still owes their share for that card. In a Peer Trade, the card goes back to the Sender, the forfeited fee and the return costs are refunded and the trade stays cancelled, or, after delivery, the receiver keeps GrailMine's payment, the Sender owes nothing and the card stays GrailMine's.

2.4 Ways to Protect Yourself Before You Buy

  • Request a live inspection of any listed card before purchasing. You see the actual card on camera, and the recording can be used as evidence.
  • Check the seller's trust profile and the listing photographs.
  • Keep your conversation and payment on GrailMine. The claims process applies only to transactions completed on the platform, so an off-platform deal has no protection.

2.5 Chargebacks

You can also dispute a charge with your card issuer. A chargeback is decided by the card networks, not by GrailMine. If you win one, GrailMine bears the loss and the seller owes GrailMine the amount lost as a debt. GrailMine's claims process is separate and is usually faster, so open a claim first.

3. For Sellers

3.1 What Protects You

  • Tracking on every order. An order cannot be marked shipped without a valid tracking number. A sale without tracking cannot be defended if a buyer says it never arrived.
  • Signature confirmation on orders with a card subtotal of $750 or more (before shipping and tax). It is required, and GrailMine labels include it automatically. It is the strongest evidence of delivery, but it does not change when you are paid or who bears the cost of a chargeback.
  • Good records. Keep the shipping receipt, photographs of the card and the sealed package, and any live inspection recording.

3.2 Chargebacks and Fees

If a buyer's bank reverses a charge, Stripe takes the amount, and a $15 dispute fee, from GrailMine. If GrailMine contests the chargeback, Stripe charges a second $15 fee, the countered fee. GrailMine bears Stripe's dispute fees on marketplace sales in every outcome, and they are never added to what a seller owes. GrailMine does not take the seller's share back when a chargeback opens. It pauses the payout for that order until the card network decides, or 90 days after the chargeback opens, whichever comes first.

OutcomeWhat happens
The seller winsThe paused payout is released, and GrailMine keeps its commission, the Payment processing line and the Low-Value Order Fee where they apply.
The buyer winsThe seller owes GrailMine the amount lost as a debt, whenever the loss is decided, and the seller keeps nothing from the order. GrailMine keeps no commission, no Payment processing line and no Low-Value Order Fee, charges no handling fee, and bears Stripe's dispute fees.

A GrailMine administrator reviews every chargeback and decides whether to contest it. GrailMine contests it only if you are not at fault; where the buyer deserves the refund, it does not contest.

How GrailMine recovers what a seller owes. Each debt (a refund, a lost chargeback or a carrier adjustment on a label) is recorded, and GrailMine sends the seller a notice by email and on the dashboard stating the amount, the order and the reason before the first recovery step. GrailMine recovers it in this order, never more than the amount of the debt: that order's share if it has not been paid out, a later payout, the card the seller has on file, then an invoice. Where an administrator decides that a refund was seller-caused (counterfeit, not as described, or never arrives), the debt also includes the actual label cost and GrailMine's actual out-of-pocket costs, at cost with no markup. A refund a seller gives voluntarily, outside a dispute, is not seller-caused. Carrier adjustments on labels GrailMine bought are charged at the billed amount, with no markup, and credited back if GrailMine's dispute with its shipping provider is upheld.

3.3 Who Keeps the Commission When an Order Is Refunded

When an order is refunded in full, whether through a claim, a dispute, a cancellation or a chargeback, the order is void: GrailMine keeps no commission, no Payment processing line and no Low-Value Order Fee, and charges no handling fee, and the seller keeps nothing from it. Stripe does not return its processing fee, so that fee is GrailMine's cost. When the seller wins a dispute, GrailMine keeps its commission, the Payment processing line and the Low-Value Order Fee.

When only part of an order is refunded, GrailMine gives up its commission and the percentage part of the Payment processing line only on the amount refunded, and keeps the rest of its fees on the order, including the fixed $0.30 part of the Payment processing line and any Low-Value Order Fee. The seller's debt for a partial refund is the amount refunded, less the commission and Payment processing line GrailMine gives up on it.

3.4 When You Are Paid

Your payout is released when the carrier confirms delivery, at every order size, or 14 days after the carrier's acceptance scan if delivery is never scanned. Released earnings are paid to your bank automatically every Friday (UTC), and you can cash out available earnings at any time. A claim on the order pauses release for up to 10 business days (a counterfeit claim, until 10 business days after GrailMine receives the card and never more than 30 days after the claim opened), a fraud review for up to 30 days, and a chargeback until the card network decides or 90 days after it opens.

3.5 GrailMine Inspected (Routed Orders)

An order from one seller that includes a card with an item price of $250 or more (the higher of the listing price and any agreed price, before shipping and tax) is a Routed Order. The seller ships the whole order to GrailMine, which photographs every card it receives, makes a limited check of each card priced at $250 or more for clear signs of counterfeiting, and ships the order to the buyer. Listings and checkout show "GrailMine Inspection included", and "GrailMine Inspected" after a card passes. The check is limited and made in good faith. It can contain errors. It is not an authentication, grade, certification or guarantee, and a card that passes can still be the subject of a claim. GrailMine's stated time is 7 business days from the carrier's delivery of the order to GrailMine to its first scan of the shipment to the buyer, not counting weekends or USPS holidays. If GrailMine runs over, the buyer gets a new date and a free way to cancel, and at 14 business days GrailMine cancels and refunds the buyer in full. If the check finds clear signs of counterfeiting, is inconclusive, or finds a card not as listed, the order (or the part with that card) is cancelled and the buyer is refunded before the seller is paid. GrailMine keeps a counterfeit card; in the other cases it returns the card to the seller. GrailMine is responsible for loss or damage to a card while it holds it, up to the card's item price and, for a card that is not graded, no more than $1,000. GrailMine pays for its shipment to the buyer (postage, packaging and signature). Nothing is deducted from the seller's share for it, and the seller owes nothing for it even if that parcel is lost. At a card subtotal (the total item price, before shipping and tax) of $750 or more, GrailMine buys carrier insurance on that shipment at its own cost, for the item price of the cards or the carrier's maximum for the service, whichever is lower. The seller's payout is unchanged: it is released when the carrier confirms delivery of GrailMine's shipment to the buyer, and it does not depend on the check. When the check finds clear signs of counterfeiting, the seller has 14 days to ask for a grading review of the card (see section 2.3).

4. Peer Trades

In a Peer Trade, both traders send their cards to GrailMine. GrailMine inspects each card it receives, buys each card that passes inspection, and sells each trader the card they agreed to receive. Each trader's contract is with GrailMine, and GrailMine is not an agent, broker or escrow holder for either trader.

  • Each trader pays a trade fee (sales tax, where it applies, is added on top). If a trade fails and only one trader is at fault, only that trader's fee is forfeited, and the other trader is refunded in full and has their card returned at GrailMine's expense.
  • Every trade is completed or cancelled within 30 days after it becomes binding. A trade that cannot be completed by then is cancelled.
  • Where a trader buys their USPS label to GrailMine through GrailMine, it is at actual cost with no markup, charged to the card used for their trade fee. If the trade fails because the other trader was at fault, or because GrailMine could not complete it, GrailMine refunds that label.
  • A trader whose fee was forfeited can contest it. An administrator reviews the appeal.
  • GrailMine keeps every card it finds clearly counterfeit at intake, including a first-time Sender's card, and does not return it. The Sender pays return postage and insurance only on the other trader's card. The Sender has 14 days to ask for a grading review (see section 2.3).
  • Every card GrailMine returns in a failed or cancelled trade is insured automatically with the carrier (shipping insurance (carrier)), for the card's Locked Trade Value or the highest amount the carrier offers for the service used, whichever is lower. GrailMine buys it, and it is never an optional extra on a return. When a trade fails because a trader is at fault, GrailMine pays for every return first (postage and shipping insurance) and returns the cards promptly. GrailMine then charges the at-fault trader the full actual cost of returning both traders' cards, at cost with no markup, to the payment method they used for their trade fee, whatever the cards are worth. If the charge fails, the cards still go back and the amount becomes a debt: GrailMine never holds a card for an unpaid charge. If both traders are at fault, each pays to return their own card. If neither trader is at fault, or an inspection is inconclusive, or GrailMine could not complete the trade, GrailMine pays for every return. There is no charge for packing materials or handling on a return, and no sales tax on the charge.
  • A trader can bring a claim that a card is counterfeit within 30 days after it is delivered, even if it passed inspection. Inspection is not a guarantee of authenticity. The receiving trader must send the card back to GrailMine on a prepaid tracked label within 14 days, or the claim is denied. GrailMine pays for that label and insures that shipment (shipping insurance (carrier)), for the card's Locked Trade Value or the highest amount the carrier offers for the service used, whichever is lower, and bears the risk of its loss in transit. A confirmed counterfeit is never returned to either trader, and the trader who sent it has 14 days to ask for a grading review (see section 2.3). If the claim is denied after GrailMine has the card, GrailMine returns it at its own expense, with shipping insurance (carrier) for the card's Locked Trade Value or the highest amount the carrier offers for the service used, whichever is lower. The trader who sent a confirmed counterfeit is at fault, and GrailMine may recover the claimant's loss from that trader. GrailMine is not the insurer of any trade and does not guarantee recovery.
  • If a trader who paid Top-up cash is found at fault for a chargeback on it (other than a charge they did not authorize), that trader owes GrailMine the amount lost plus Stripe's dispute fee, and the countered fee if GrailMine contested and lost.
  • When you accept a trade, you can choose shipping insurance (carrier) for the cards shipped to you, at the carrier's actual charge with no markup. GrailMine is not an insurer and does not sell insurance. Loss or damage in transit is covered by the carrier: up to the coverage the carrier includes at no charge, if any, or up to the insured amount if you chose it. GrailMine files the claim with the carrier and passes through what the carrier pays on an approved claim, without deducting processing fees. GrailMine does not guarantee that the carrier approves a claim.
  • Raw (ungraded) cards with a value above $1,000 are not accepted at this time. Graded cards above $1,000 are allowed.

5. What Protection Does Not Cover

  • Buyer's remorse or a change of mind.
  • Claims brought after the windows above.
  • Transactions arranged or paid for outside GrailMine.
  • Losses beyond the limits of liability in the Terms of Service.

6. More Information

  • Terms of Service
  • Return and Refund Policy
  • Seller Shipping Standards

7. Contact

Rift Exchange, LLC, Virginia. Email: support@grailmine.com.

All policies

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • GrailMine Protection
  • Recording Policy
  • Seller Shipping Standards
  • Return and Refund Policy
ResourcesCustomer ServiceTerms of ServicePrivacy PolicyRecording PolicyReturn and Refund PolicyCopyright and DMCAAccessibility
© 2026 Rift Exchange, LLC. All rights reserved.